Eigenvalues over two parameters: the tilted double well

This tutorial computes the eigenvalues as functions of two parameters of the potential and plots them as a two-dimensional map, using the two-parameter sweeps and the plotting functions introduced in FEMTISE v0.2.0. The system is a particle (mass 1, atomic units) in the tilted double well

\[\hat H = -\frac{1}{2}\frac{d^2}{dx^2} + \lambda\,(x^2-1)^2 + \mu\,x ,\]

where $\lambda$ is the height of the barrier between the minima at $x = \pm1$ and $\mu$ the tilt. In the symmetric well ($\mu = 0$) the two lowest states are the symmetric and antisymmetric combinations of the states localized in each well; their tunnelling splitting $\varepsilon_1-\varepsilon_0$ decreases exponentially as the barrier grows. A tilt localizes the states in one well, and the gap approaches the energy difference between the wells, $\approx 2\mu$.

All files are in src/double_well_parameter_map/ of the FEMTISE_TUTORIAL repository.

1. The potential

adhoc_potential_function.jl:

function double_well(x, params::Tuple)
    λ, μ = params
    return λ * (x[1]^2 - 1)^2 + μ * x[1]
end

2. The input file

The first parameter is swept with analysis_param and the second one with the optional setting analysis_param_2. Both have the form index initial_value final_value step:

full_path_name              = ./output/double_well_map
dom_type                    = s
nev                         = 4
dimension                   = 1D
sigma                       = -2.0
adhoc_file_name             = ./adhoc_potential_function
potential_function_name     = double_well
params_potential_types      = f f
params_potential            = 1.0 0.0
analysis_param              = 1 0.75 10.0 0.25
output_format_type          = jld2 eigen
## ONLY FOR 1D EIGENPROBLEMS
L                           = 8.0
Δx                          = 0.02
## ONLY FOR 2D EIGENPROBLEMS
Lx                          =
Ly                          =
nx                          =
ny                          =
different_masses            =
reduced_density             =
## OPTIONAL SETTINGS (FEMTISE v0.2.0)
analysis_param_2            = 2 -0.05 1.0 0.05
quadrature_degree           = 8

The driver evaluates $\lambda_i + k\,\Delta\lambda$ for $k = 1, 2, \dots$, so the values above give $\lambda = 1.0, 1.25, \dots, 10.0$ (37 values) and $\mu = 0.0, 0.05, \dots, 1.0$ (21 values): 777 eigenvalue problems, solved on the same mesh and finite element spaces. quadrature_degree = 8 integrates the quartic potential exactly, so the eigenvalues are upper bounds.

The same sweep with the low-level interface:

V(x, λ, μ) = λ * (x[1]^2 - 1)^2 + μ * x[1]
model = CartesianDiscreteModel((-4.0, 4.0), (400,))
E = sweep_eigenvalues(model, V, 1.0:0.25:10.0, 0.0:0.05:1.0; nev = 4, sigma = -2.0,
                      quadrature_degree = 8)              # E[n, i, j]

3. Running the tutorial

julia --project=. src/double_well_parameter_map/run_tutorial.jl

The results are reloaded with collect_result_data, which returns an AnalysisParams2D with the fields ϵ_tensor (ϵ_tensor[n, i, j] is the $n$-th eigenvalue at $\lambda_i$, $\mu_j$), λvector and μvector. The figures are drawn by the plotting functions of FEMTISE, available when a Makie backend is loaded:

using CairoMakie
fig = plot_energy_map(λ, μ, E; gap = (1, 2), colorscale = log10)   # ε₁ − ε₀
fig = plot_energy_curves(λ, E[:, :, 1])                             # cut at μ = 0

4. Results

Energy gap over barrier height and tilt

Gap between the two lowest levels over the barrier height $\lambda$ and the tilt $\mu$, on a logarithmic colour scale with level lines equally spaced in $\log_{10}(\varepsilon_1-\varepsilon_0)$. At $\mu = 0$ the gap is the tunnelling splitting, which drops from 0.79 hartree at $\lambda = 1$ to 0.13 hartree at $\lambda = 10$ (dark corner). For large barriers a small tilt is enough to destroy the tunnelling doublet: the level lines turn horizontal and the gap is set by the energy difference of the two wells.

Eigenvalues of the symmetric double well

The four lowest eigenvalues of the symmetric well ($\mu = 0$) as functions of the barrier height. As $\lambda$ grows, the levels pair up into tunnelling doublets: the ground state (thick line) and the first excited state approach each other.

5. Things to try

  • Plot a single eigenvalue instead of a gap: plot_energy_map(λ, μ, E; level = 1).
  • Plot the gap between the second doublet and the ground state, gap = (1, 3), and compare with the vibrational frequency of each well, $\approx\sqrt{8\lambda}$.
  • Extend the barrier range and observe the exponential decrease of the splitting on the logarithmic colour scale.